Story helps, but I think the story in games is always inferior to a good book or even a good film. When it comes to games, I want gameplay, and that's what I'm talking about. As for story in a game, if you only care about that and don't care so much about gameplay, then adventure games are the place to be.
Everquest your best RPG? *wow*
Have you even played it?
@voodoochile123: Lol, your rants are funny. But I am not sure you would recognize an RPG if it hit you in the head. Yes, witcher 2 has a needlessly complicated combat system
Back at you. My rant about the combat is not that it's too complicated, it's that it's too simple. If you find The Witcher complicated, I dread to think how you would handle a party based RPG like Icewind Dale or something.
The mainstream definition of RPG has shifted, and that's what he's railing about. I have friends who've mentioned this.
I'll read that soon. For what it's worth, I don't care much about the definition all that much, as I never buy anything without researching it thoroughly anyway. What does bug me though is that there just aren't any good true old school RPG's anymore. They are all simplified for the modern gamer and all just glorified hack n slashers. I want ones with riddles, where fire creatures resist fire magic, where magic creatures are immune to damage unless you have a magical weapon, where you can be poisoned and diseased, where people are expected to know what dexterity and constitution means, etc.. But you just don't get them like that anymore. The only one I'm even vaguely interested in, is Skyrim, and even that is just an action game.
IIronically, with regards to Rainbow Six being mentioned - Ghost Recon Advanced Warfighter is exactly like that. R6: Vegas 2 is a little more casual but you still can't take much in the way of hits. What this has to do with RPGs though, who knows.
Vegas 2 is as dumb as it gets. They removed the planning stages completely, and no more multiple entrances and squad switching. You have a radar showing you where all the enemies are before you reach them, so there are no surprises. You can be shot with a machine gun, step behind a wall for a few seconds, and your health completely regenerates. It's just gaming for the Gears of War generation. If I want a tough shooter, luckily I have Arma 2, but games like that are out there on their own these days. For every game like that, there are 50 mindless shooters and zombie bashers.
It is related to RPG's, because it's a trend that is happening to games in general, not just RPG's. It has happened to shooters, to RPG's, and also to RTS's. Look at Forged Alliance and compare it with Supreme Commander 2. Or even games like World in Conflict where you don't even have base building anymore, you just control a handful of units now. MMO's? Look at WoW compared to Ultima Online, and now everything else has gone the same way WoW went and games like UO just don't even exist any more. There are only a few genres left that aren't completely dumb now, TBS seems to be ok, and flight sims, there are only even a few of those left now, sadly one being HAWX, but at least there is DCS.
As I read somewhere recently, there is no "middle class" left in gaming now. It's all huge mainstream Call of Duty type games , and tiny independent World of Goo type games, and very little in between. So if you are the kind of person that likes the big mainstream games, then it's happy days for you. But if like me you want more than just flashy graphics, then you are screwed.
p.s. I'm gone now. I'll leave you all with this:
http://social.bioware.com/forum/1/topic/141/index/7126490