I for one feel that they owe it to us to at least fix the invalid gamestate and constant crashes with this game. It is no way to do business to not completely fix this game to a consistently playable level before moving on to the next project. It is bad business and will earn GPG and Stardock a reputation they can do without. I for one really enjoy the game and get about 65-70 % of my games completed without errors of some kind ( counting other players bugging out). Some of this may be through the players own problems, but most of it is the game. Think about it, lobbies time out, password randomly resets on me and many other things. I feel that by posting about this Im just pissing in the wind though.
I feel like I've gotten my money out of demigod. I played ALOT of games. I enjoyed ALOT of games.
Here's the negative. Yes, it is right to feel that a company selling a game FOCUSED ON MULTIPLAYER should provide a good MULTIPLAYER experience. Is the multiplayer experience great? No. It is not. Is the multilayer experience good? No. It is not. Seriously - ask yourself if you think the MP experience is good. It ain't.
Are MP stats easily skewed? Yes. Is it easy to cheat? Yes. Will they fix the exploits at this point? No.
You will not get automatic fair matchmaking with this game. Any MP focused decent gameplay out today will provide this. What you can get is automatic matchmaking in pantheon. This means that if you choose forces of light, you will lose the 1v1 game you will fight against Erebus. If you choose erebus - you will either win or likely wait a very long time to play. In short, the multiplayer experience is okay if you have an experienced buddy willing to walk you through the paces or are experienced with MP gaming. But only if.
I bought demigod after reading a review that it was a diamond in the rough. Excellent gameplay, but plagued by pirates at launch and MP issues. I knew I was getting into a great game with terrbile issues. I had hoped most of the issues would be overcome, but many remain... now to the point that we can't expect any fixes in a reasonable timeframe. Eg - I expect the next patch in > 6 months at this point, if at all. And when I say patch, I mean changes that anyone will care about.
I really wish this was a game developed and published by SD. Alot of this sounds like a gripe against them, but frankly, I'm really confident that this game would have been a labor of love for brad if it was his IP. He would have turned this into something amazing. This could have been your counterstrike. We'd see our bug fixes at the very least. As it is, I could fix most of the bugs in demigod in 2 hours thanks to our great community. If only I could get the fixed version of dgdata.zip released. So, 2 hours of my time to get a compiled dgdata.zip. Then SD distributes that and we have our bug fixes.... but thanks to the corporate model or something... oh well.